repetition and the face of America…

Posted on Thursday 19 July 2007

We do the same things over and over – we human beings. In fact, our repetitions essentially define us as individuals. If you know a person well, you can predict with sometimes astonishing accuracy just how that person will respond in a given situation. Independent of how one explains this remarkable phenomenon – whether by Learning Theory or by the Psychoanalytic "repetition compulsion" – you can’t avoid the fact that the very thing we call "personality" is a collection of our repetitions. A couple of old sayings:
  • The best predictor of future behavior is past behavior.
  • Insanity is doing the same thing over and over, expecting different results.
Since we’re all so predictable, one way to define "health" is that a person is capable of acting "out of character" when their usual style is not appropriate to the given life situation. People with what are called Personality Disorders repeat themselves, even when it is to their own detriment. Their character traits are so rigidly fixed that they literally can’t have any flexibility in their responses.

Right now, we’re watching this phenomena play out in our two leaders, George W. Bush and Dick Cheney. Both men are locked into monotonous patterns of behavior that seem impervious to any input from the outside. Neither of them seems capable of learning from their mistakes. Neither man seems capable of coming up with any new solutions in response to new information. But worse than that, they both appear to be enslaved by their personalities. It’s apparent to even the most casual observer that what we’re doing in Iraq isn’t working. Even their most ardent supporters see that. But they don’t budge. They’re throwing away money and human lives at an alarming rate, but continue to rale about Democrats being big spenders. Worse, they both are unwilling to listen to anyone else, so they reflexly resist Congress, advisors [like the Iraq Study Group], popular opinion. They both have a quality that is characteristic of what is called Narcissism – they believe their own thoughts are correct – absolutely. When they are questioned, they both immediately go into a defensive mode and start looking for ways to counter their critics, rather than listening to what the critics are saying. It’s automatic. And they both sneer on the way…

But, there are some differences between the two men – at least that’s how it appears to me. Dick Cheney seems to have no moral compass – no bedrock attachment to the truth. In the Valerie Plame Affair, he immediately responded with political skullduggery. In the buildup to the war, he immediately jumped on the slimmest hint of intelligence about Hussein and dogged the C.I.A. until he had his reasons to justify invading Iraq. His [now] Chief of Staff, David Addington, seems to work full time making up rationalizations for him to do whatever he wants to do. In the recent series in the Washington Post, there were example after example of hasty rationalizations that he jumped on, even though they turned out to be disasters – like the massive Salmon Kill in the Northwest. When there’s something he wants to accomplish, he begins to look for a way to do it, a loophole or rationalization, never looking at the fact that the things in his way are there for a very good reason. His contempt for oversight has become legend.

Not that George W. Bush is any moral giant. But he doesn’t seem to me to be so dark a figure as Dick Cheney. He strikes me more like a spoiled brat who wants his way and surrounds himself with people who help him get it. Whatever the case, I don’t trust either one of them to act responsibly to new challenges. They are both enslaved by their personalities. The best predictor of their future behavior is their past behavior. Their insanity is doing the same things over and over, claiming that there will be different results.

I doubt that they’ll do anything to change the course of events in Iraq. I expect they’ll continue to "stay the course" to the end unless Congress finds some method to make that completely impossible. I doubt that they’ll do anything about the fact that we currently have no effective Federal Justice System in our country right now. They’ll keep nickle and diming Congress to the bitter end and leave Alberto Gonzales exactly where he is. I’m skeptical that they’ll do anything about their decimation of our military forces and our abuse of our own troops. They are going to continue to inflict their disordered personality structures on the American people until they can no longer exert any influence – and they’re good at it. And they’ll continue to make "the sneer" the face of America.

 

What worries me is a specific kind of repeating. We’re due for another Terrorist attack. They used the last one [9/11] to justify something they came into office wanting to do – go to war with Iraq. They lied to make it work. I have no doubt that they’ll try to use the next one to justify something else they want to do – go to war with Iran. They’ve already set the stage. That’s the repetition that worries me the most right now. I hope it worries all of us…
  1.  
    joyhollywood
    July 19, 2007 | 8:38 AM
     

    I know that this is a little off track but if I hear that the Bush Administration has to be doing the right thing in this country because we haven’t been attacked in 6 years from another Republican Senator I will attempt to jump thru the tv screen. No one ever mentions that the first attack at the World Trade Center was in 1993 and most of the people responsible were convicted and put in jail for life in the Clinton Administration. If my math is correct, it was 8 years between attacks but we know from Republicans that Clinton hardly ever did anything right. My daughter in law was walking into the second building when the second plane hit. I know just a little bit about the fear of not knowing if a loved one is alive or dead. 2 of the most vocal widows of 911 live in our town. When I walk in the memorial garden at our civic center I say a pray for their families and all the families of 911. Bush not only stayed on vacation after getting the memo Bin Laden determined to strike in U. S. but he didn’t even have a meeting about the threat. I’m not saying that Bush let this happen, but he did use the event to go after Sadaam and Iraq. Bush and Cheney will use any excuse to bomb Iran. We need Powell to go before the cameras to make a major announcement to the American people. He needs to tell the people the truth about the President and Vice President and their race to war in Iraq before history repeats itself. We need the major networks to have real breaking news bulletins to expose this White House before it’s too late.

  2.  
    July 19, 2007 | 9:16 AM
     

    Well put. That’s exactly what I want from Powell – the whole truth. What a story about your daughter-in-law. I’m glad she made it.

    “I’m not saying that Bush let this happen.” I’m not sure I’d let him off the hook yet. I’m not generally big on conspiracy theories, but I still wonder if there wasn’t a method in their laxity about al Qaeda…

  3.  
    Kayden
    August 18, 2007 | 6:19 PM
     

    hi nice post, i enjoyed it

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.