another anniversary…

Posted on Thursday 7 March 2013

This blog began in 2005. It was a Christmas present from my daughter. She named it 1boringoldman because on a former blog with two other friends that was supposed to be news about our retirements, the only person writing was me, and I could only talk about one thing – the Invasion of Iraq. A few months earlier, I had discovered a brand new blog – the Huffington Post – that was as monotonous as I was. My first post here, two days after Christmas that year, quoted Arianna. And for the next three years, I wrote about little except the Iraq War. When Bush and Cheney left Washington, I was finally able to write about something closer to home – psychiatry. Back then, the Huffington Post was not media as it is now – just a few bloggers as obsessed with the wrongness of that war as I was. So I interrupt the dialog about psychiatry for this reminder from Arianna and as an alert to her coming coverage:

"The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting." It’s one of Milan Kundera’s most famous lines, from his novel The Book of Laughter and Forgetting. It’s one worth keeping in mind as we approach March 20, the 10th anniversary of one of the biggest disasters in the history of the United States. That was the day George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, and a team of others – along with much of Washington and a very complicit mainstream media — took the nation to war against Iraq. The devastating consequences of that war will continue for decades, but a full accounting has still yet to happen. And that in itself has consequences. Allowing the toxic mixture of lies, deception and rationalizations that led to that war to go unchallenged makes it more likely that we will make similar tragic mistakes in the future. So I hope we can use this moment to assess what really happened, to look back in order to look forward.

At HuffPost, we’ll be doing what we can in that effort by using the anniversary to look at the war and what led up to it from all angles: Who got it right and who got it wrong? What was the role of the media? What are the ongoing consequences? We’ll be featuring analysis, blogs, video and more in an attempt to aid that struggle of memory against forgetting. Of course, the most glaring manifestation of our failure to have a collective accounting of this fiasco is that those who are most responsible for it still have loud voices in our foreign policy. "For a decade or more after the Vietnam war, the people who had guided the U.S. to disaster decently shrank from the public stage," writes James Fallows. "Rusk, Rostow, Westmoreland were not declaiming on what the U.S. should and should not do."

And yet, after what Fallows calls "the biggest strategic error by the United States since at least the end of World War II," that accounting has not happened:
    After Iraq, there has been a weird amnesty and amnesia about people’s misjudgment on the most consequential decision of our times … Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, Bremer, Rice, McCain, Abrams, and others including the pro-war press claque are still offering their judgments unfazed. He concludes: "I don’t say these people should never again weigh in. But there should be an asterisk on their views, like the fine print about side effects in pharmaceutical ads."
Actually, the warning should be a lot bigger than fine print – it should be as big and glaring as their blunders and falsehoods. There is, of course, almost no end to the lies and deceptions that led to this calamity – we will be featuring many of them in our anniversary coverage and you can also revisit them in these timelines here and here

In December of 2011, as the last combat troops were being brought home from Iraq, President Obama stood at Fort Bragg and declared, "The war in Iraq will soon belong to history." That may be true, but it’s vital that our accounting of the failures that led to this tragedy not be relegated to the past. Does President Bush, while painting his pictures in Texas, ever look back and assess the worst decision of his presidency [and that’s a pretty high bar]? It seems doubtful, but that doesn’t mean the rest of us shouldn’t. No doubt there will someday, rightly, be a monument to those who bravely fought and died in Iraq. But for the 10th anniversary, let’s also build online monuments dedicated to those who planned and provoked and fomented the war, so we can join in the struggle of memory against forgetting.
  1.  
    berit bj
    March 9, 2013 | 11:31 AM
     

    Researchers in USA reported a few days ago that the number of killing centers in Nazi Germany was far greater than they anticipated at the start a decade ago, as they also had had to raise the number of people murdered in 42.500 now known centers upwards to 12-15 million persons. Every adult German would have had to know what was going on, yet this staggeringly horrible truth took 70 years to resurface. As horrible truths elsewhere. Every year there are new books out on ugly facts hitherto hidden from the war years, Nazi-German occupation of nearly all of Europe, traitors and collaborators high and low.
    President Obama relegating the US-British war on Iraq to history, occupation and destruction, killing untold numbers of Iraqi civilians and ca 5000 young Americans, is a measure of the man’s ignorance of history, delusions of power. The reckoning is hardly begun, though there is a harsh beginning if you read the Guardian today, and watch the video about American citizen James Steel and the counter-insurgency instigated on behalf of America’s then top brass Petreus/Rumfeldt/Bush. The “rules were of engagement, not rule of law”, i e anyting goes by way of detention, torture, death. Whatever diagnosis the masters of political science may settle for, Fascism, neo-colonialism, ambitions of empire, I prefer Hubris, the ultimate lunacy of power.

  2.  
    Annonymous
    March 9, 2013 | 11:42 AM
     

    To draw a direct comparison between what is detailed in the New York Times article you reference, and the counterinsurgency in Iraq, is to me inappropriate to say the least. Regardless of one’s views on the wrongness of the Iraq war. Given that that is not my primary focus when I engage with this blog I will leave it at that.

  3.  
    berit bj
    March 9, 2013 | 5:14 PM
     

    War crimes and crimes against humanity resonate through generations, whether the wars are regional, as in the Middle East, or world conflagrations, as WWs 1 and 2. To hope that the illegal US-British Iraq war should be history 10 years after the invasion in 2003 is seen – from this other side of the Atlantic Ocean – as one more presidential delusion.
    The new research documenting a stunningly high number of killing sites in Nazi-Germany has been in all major European media. The number of secret detention senters, in and out of Iraq, detainees tortured, brutalized,many killed, is hardly on this scale. Some day it may be known. But still, great damage has been done. It will be resonating in many men and women in lots of places for generations. It’s not comforting to know what men are capable of doing to men, not only Nazis, Americans too, like James Steele and the US warlords.

  4.  
    berit bj
    March 11, 2013 | 7:43 AM
     

    New report presented today March 11 from Amnesty International on human rights abuses in Iraq during and after the illegal war and occupation by the US-led coalition of the willing. http://www.amnesty.org

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.