Thumbs Down…

Posted on Monday 11 August 2008

I’m still not able to spend much time on the computer, but a friend called my attention to Maureen Dowd’s take on John Edwards:

So a narcissist walks into a New York bar and meets a legendarily wacky former Gotham party girl – whose ’80s exploits were chronicled in a novel by her former boyfriend Jay McInerney because the behavior of her and her friends "intrigued and appalled me." When you appall Jay McInerney, you know you’re in trouble.
Certain men assume that power confers sexual privilege. And in American politics, there is an eternal disjunction between character and achievement. Sinners do good things, saints do bad things.

Still, it’s bizarre the way these pols spend millions getting their faces plastered everywhere and then think they can do something in secret. "Yeah, I didn’t think anyone would ever know about it, I didn’t," Edwards said.

In one of the Web films Hunter directed, he actually flirts with the blonde, laughingly telling her that his address on morality is "a great speech" and complaining, "Why don’t you hear me give it live?"

For some reason, super-strivers have a need to sell what is secretly weakest about themselves, as if they yearn for unmasking.

Edwards’ decency and concern for the weak in society – except for his own wife. Bill Clinton’s intellect and love of community – except for his stupidity and destructiveness about Monica. Bush the Younger’s jocular, I’m-in-charge self-confidence – except for turning over his presidency, as no president ever has, to his Veep. Eliot Spitzer’s crusade for truth, justice and the American way – except at home.

In the Hunter video titled "Plane Truths," Edwards is relaxing on his plane, telling the out-of-frame director: "I’ve come to the personal conclusion that I actually want the country to see who I am, who I really am, but I don’t know what the result of that will be. But for me personally, I’d rather be successful or unsuccessful based on who I really am, not based on some plastic Ken doll that you put up in front of audiences." Ken couldn’t have said it better.

Back in 2002, Edwards sent me a Ken doll dressed in bathing trunks, Rio de Janeiro Ken, with a teasing note, because he didn’t like my reference to him as a Ken doll in a column.

In retrospect, the comparison was not fair – to Ken.
I am sometimes put off but Dowd’s columns. They move over to line of good commentary into tacky talk. But this one is dead on. I’ve wanted to like Edwards since 2004 when he ran with Kerry, but I just felt uneasy when I watched him – kind of like "cotton candy" at the Fair as a kid. I met a guy on an Africa trip who knew him. He said, "That haircut story – that’s the truth. That’s what he’s like." And the TV interview was as Dowd describes it:
Auto-psychoanalysis by the perp. That’s really rich. When Bill Clinton acknowledged an affair, after equally adamant denials, he simply went into an old-fashioned spiral of penitence, his allegedly long, dark night of his alleged soul.
 
Even in confessing to preening, Edwards was preening. His diagnosis of narcissism was weirdly narcissistic, or was it self-narcissistic? Given his diagnosis, I’m sure his HMO would pay.
 
The creepiest part of his creepy confession was when he stressed to Woodruff that he cheated on Elizabeth in 2006 when her cancer was in remission. His infidelity was oncologically correct.
I think that John Edwards is an example of our system getting it right – Thumbs Down
  1.  
    joyhollywood
    August 12, 2008 | 7:45 AM
     

    It’s so good to read something from you. The book that I have been writing you about “The Dark Side” deals a lot with your medical expertise. I agree with what you say about Dowd but I have to add something has really been missing with the opinion page for a couple of years now. The word that comes to my mind is it’s lack of relevance.

  2.  
    August 12, 2008 | 4:18 PM
     

    missing, hopefully not dead…

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.