from Israel…

Posted on Wednesday 21 May 2008

With Barack Obama close to clinching the Democratic nomination, Republicans have stepped up their efforts to woo Jewish voters who have doubts about the senator’s support for Israel and his overall Middle East policy. Using fear tactics, groups like the Republican Jewish Coalition have played the "Israel card" to tip the balance come November. Four years ago, I would have been persuaded. Not this time.

Yes, back then the fear tactics worked, and they made me prefer President Bush over Senator Kerry. I was a college pro-Israel activist – needless to say in a very difficult time for Israel advocacy – and I needed some moral comfort, some moral clarity. While I recognized that Kerry was a smart guy, and I did like him overall, Bush’s black and white clarity was more comforting. I was convinced that such beliefs were essential for a post-9/11 world and an unrelenting war against terror. Since Jewish voters whose main concern was Israel were telling me they supported Bush, I decided to join the club.

That was a huge mistake, but an eye-opening experience about campaigns and fear tactics. Today, neoconservatives are trying to do the same, but this time I am supporting whoever gets the Democratic nomination. I already know that Senator Clinton is a staunch supporter of Israel, and I have become convinced that Senator Obama would be as well. This time, using the "Israel card" will not work for the Republicans in attracting the Jewish vote.

SENATOR OBAMA’s interview with Jeffrey Goldberg in The Atlantic represents some of the most reassuring words I have heard from the Democratic front-runner regarding his Middle East policy, and especially his support for Israel. Rather than only seeing Israel as a "strategic ally" or as the "only democracy in the Middle East" – the standard clichés of support – Senator Obama identifies with the "Zionist idea" and believes that a secure Jewish state is "fundamentally just"…
I’ve been haunting the Israeli papers since Bush’s speech and I haven’t been altogether happy with what I’ve found. I support the State of Israel. But I don’t support their expansionism, and I really don’t support their mistreatment of the Palestinians. In that conflict, there are no heros. Both sides need to step up to the plate and change directions. So today, I read this editorial/op-ed piece. It’s very thoughtful and, in my opinion, fundamentally correct. Like Obama, I support the right of the Jewish State in Israel. Unlike many, I do not support the notion that the Jews are the chosen people who can do whatever they want to do. There’s more to the Torah than the "promised land." There’s a code of ethics and an obligation. In this piece and others by SALOMON KALACH, I think he understands that. I also think he sees that Barack Obama is a thoughtful person, unlike our current impulsive and simplistic President [I’d bet George W. Bush couldn’t pass a high school history test on what happened in Germany with Chamberlin in 1938]. I appreciate the Jerusalem Post publishing this essay…

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.